Indianapolis is home to a thriving food scene, offering everything from upscale dining experiences to hidden local gems. Whether you’re new to the city or a longtime resident looking for a new favorite spot, here are some of the best restaurants in Indianapolis you need to try.
1. St. Elmo Steak House
A legendary Indianapolis institution, St. Elmo Steak House is famous for its prime steaks and world-renowned shrimp cocktail. This classic spot is a must-visit for steak lovers and those seeking a fine dining experience.
2. Bluebeard
Located in the historic Fletcher Place neighborhood, Bluebeard offers a farm-to-table menu with creative dishes inspired by seasonal ingredients. The atmosphere is cozy, making it perfect for date nights or special occasions.
3. Milktooth
For brunch enthusiasts, Milktooth is a must. This trendy eatery has gained national recognition for its innovative breakfast and brunch offerings, including unique waffles, Dutch babies, and craft coffee.
4. The Eagle
If you’re in the mood for Southern comfort food, The Eagle is the place to be. Their fried chicken is a fan favorite, and their homemade sides like mac and cheese and cornbread are equally delicious.
5. Livery
Serving Latin-inspired cuisine, Livery offers flavorful empanadas, tacos, and handcrafted cocktails in a stylish setting. Their rooftop dining option is perfect for a great night out in downtown Indy.
6. Tinker Street
For a cozy, intimate dining experience, Tinker Street offers an ever-changing menu of fresh, locally sourced dishes. Their wine selection and small plates make it a great spot for foodies.
7. Tony’s of Indianapolis
This upscale steakhouse is known for its excellent service, top-quality steaks, and extensive wine list. A great choice for business dinners or celebratory occasions.
8. Shapiro’s Delicatessen
A staple in Indianapolis for over 100 years, Shapiro’s Delicatessen serves up some of the best sandwiches in the city. Their pastrami on rye and matzo ball soup are customer favorites.
9. Mama Carolla’s Old Italian Restaurant
If you’re craving Italian cuisine, Mama Carolla’s is a charming spot with a cozy ambiance and homemade pasta dishes that keep people coming back.
10. Oakleys Bistro
This hidden gem is known for its creative American cuisine, using fresh, local ingredients. The beautifully plated dishes make for both an aesthetic and flavorful dining experience.
Explore the Indianapolis Food Scene
Whether you’re looking for fine dining, casual eats, or hidden gems, Indianapolis has something for every food lover. Thinking of moving to Indy? Contact us to learn more about the best neighborhoods close to these fantastic dining spots!
Best restaurants in Indianapolis
