Whether you’re a new resident, a longtime local, or just scoping out the city before making a move, knowing where to get a great slice is essential. Indianapolis may be known for its racing and sports teams, but its pizza scene is seriously underrated. From family-owned pizzerias to hip artisan spots, the city delivers flavor for every kind of pizza lover.
Here’s your guide to finding the best pizza in Indianapolis:
1. Bazbeaux Pizza
Location: Downtown Indy, Broad Ripple, Carmel
Bazbeaux has been serving up gourmet pizza since 1986 and is a go-to for locals. With a massive menu and crust options including whole wheat and gluten-free, there’s something for everyone.
-
Must Try: The “Tchoupitoulas” with shrimp, andouille, and Cajun spices
-
Vibe: Casual, artsy, perfect for dine-in or takeout
2. Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza
Location: Irvington, Greenwood, and Lawrence
Jockamo is known for its creative flavor combinations and high-quality ingredients. They offer both traditional and adventurous toppings in a friendly, neighborhood setting.
-
Must Try: The “Slaughterhouse Five” or “Pesto Veggie”
-
Bonus: Vegan and gluten-free options available
3. King Dough
Location: Holy Cross neighborhood
If wood-fired Neapolitan pizza is your thing, King Dough is your spot. Their crust is perfectly chewy with that classic char, and their ingredients are super fresh.
-
Must Try: The “Bee Keeper” with spicy salami and hot honey
-
Vibe: Trendy, with a cozy, hip atmosphere
4. Goodfellas Pizzeria
Location: Massachusetts Ave (Mass Ave)
This New York-style pizza joint serves massive slices and whole pies. It’s a late-night favorite and a must-visit if you like foldable, cheesy slices.
-
Must Try: Classic Pepperoni or The Big Apple
-
Fun Fact: There’s a hidden speakeasy bar in the back!
5. Napolese Pizzeria
Location: Multiple Indy locations
From the folks behind Cafe Patachou, Napolese offers artisan pies made with local ingredients and a gourmet twist. It’s ideal for a date night or family dinner.
-
Must Try: Roasted Artichoke & Goat Cheese Pizza
-
Perks: Upscale vibe with craft wine and cocktails
6. Brozinni Pizzeria
Location: Southport
Known for its buttery garlic knuckles and huge New York-style slices, Brozinni delivers big flavors in a family-friendly setting.
-
Must Try: The “5 Borough” loaded meat pizza
-
Tip: Order extra garlic butter—it’s addictive
Final Slice
Whether you’re into thin crust or thick, classic toppings or creative combos, Indianapolis has a pizza place for you. Trying out the best pizza in Indianapolis is more than a tasty experience—it’s a great way to explore the city, its neighborhoods, and the people who make it great.
Thinking of making Indy your home? Let’s find you a place near your favorite pizza joint—or better yet, one with the perfect kitchen to bake your own! 🍕🏡
